AASP/MA Body Shop Wins Appeal Against Travelers - BodyShop Business

AASP/MA Body Shop Wins Appeal Against Travelers

Travelers alleged that Mike’s Auto Body and All Day & Night Towing were engaging in unfair business practices, challenging their rates and other charges.

The Alliance of Automotive Service Providers of Massachusetts (AASP/MA) announced a Dec. 13 court decision which ruled in favor of a member shop, Mike’s Auto Body in Fall River, and partnering business, All Day & Night Towing, against Travelers Insurance.

“This court ruling in favor of Mike’s Auto Body is a positive thing for the collision industry,” said Lucky Papageorg, executive director of AASP/MA, who testified on behalf of Mike’s Auto Body. “It may not set a precedent, but it’s surely something to be optimistic about. Body shops can fight and win.”

The appeal dismisses a small claims court magistrate ruling that favored Travelers Insurance’s claim, which alleged that Mike’s Auto Body and All Day & Night Towing were engaging in unfair business practices, challenging their rates and other charges.

“The judge found in our favor, which essentially means that the prior judgments awarded against the body shop and tow company have been vacated and they do not owe Travelers any money,” said Jordan J. Rodrigues, the attorney for the two automotive businesses.

In the end, this judge found the shops’ rates to be justified, explained Rodrigues.

“We were vindicated as the judge found our rates to be fair and not unjustified,” Rodrigues said. “The shops did their work and are entitled to be paid for the services rendered.

“It’s kind of like a David versus Goliath mentality — a billion-dollar insurance company putting all this pressure on the small business. A lot of times, these businesses get letters in the mail from insurers requesting refunds or threatening to sue for triple damages and attorney fees. Nine times out of 10, these small shops probably cave and give in. I’d like to think that maybe this win will put the brakes on that practice.”

For more information on AASP/MA, visit aaspma.org.

You May Also Like

CIECA to Hold Webinar on New Normal’s Impact on Claims

CIECA’s webinar, “The New, New Normal and the Impact on the Claims & Collision Industry”, is scheduled for Jan. 26 at 2 p.m. EST.

The Collision Industry Electronic Commerce Association (CIECA) announced that its next CIECAST webinar, “The New, New Normal and the Impact on the Claims & Collision Industry”, is scheduled for Thursday, Jan. 26 at 2 p.m. EST.

Sean Carey, who has more than 30 years of experience in the automotive industry, will host the next CIECAST: “The New, New Normal and the Impact on the Claims & Collision Industry”.

SEMA Releases Statement on Status of RPM Act

Despite strong Congressional backing and support from the racing community, the 2021-2022 Congressional session is ending without passage of the Recognizing the Support of Motorsports (RPM) Act.

SEMA Accepting Nominations for Robert E. Peterson Media Award

Presented by the SEMA Motorsports Parts Manufacturers Council, the award honors a member of the print, online or broadcast media who has made a substantial contribution to the industry within the past year.

SCRS Welcomes Industry to Open Board Meeting

The meeting, which will be held on Jan. 18 from 2-5 p.m. in Palm Springs, Calif., will update repairers on the state of the collision industry.

SEMA Seeks Speakers for 2023 Education Program

Innovative thinkers and dynamic presenters are wanted for the 2023 SEMA Show and the association’s year-round virtual education program.

Other Posts

SCRS Announces New OEM Parts Data Benefit through partslink24

partslink24 is a web portal for direct access to over 15 premium OEM part catalogs, including Audi, Porsche, BMW, Land Rover and more.

AASP/NJ Mourns Loss of Members Jack Wilson and Sal Failla

The AASP/NJ lost two longtime members, supporters and friends in early December: Jack Wilson and Sebastiano “Sal” Failla.

E-Nikio Appraisals Joins CEICA as Corporate Member

E-Nikio employs 19 appraisers and specializes in collision repair operations/repair plans, insurance claims, diminished value, fair market valuations and pre-purchase inspections.

WIN Opens Registration for Annual 2023 Educational Conference

The Women’s Industry Network (WIN) has opened registration for its 2023 Annual Educational Conference May 1-2, 2023.