AASP/MA Body Shop Wins Appeal Against Travelers - BodyShop Business

AASP/MA Body Shop Wins Appeal Against Travelers

Travelers alleged that Mike’s Auto Body and All Day & Night Towing were engaging in unfair business practices, challenging their rates and other charges.

The Alliance of Automotive Service Providers of Massachusetts (AASP/MA) announced a Dec. 13 court decision which ruled in favor of a member shop, Mike’s Auto Body in Fall River, and partnering business, All Day & Night Towing, against Travelers Insurance.

“This court ruling in favor of Mike’s Auto Body is a positive thing for the collision industry,” said Lucky Papageorg, executive director of AASP/MA, who testified on behalf of Mike’s Auto Body. “It may not set a precedent, but it’s surely something to be optimistic about. Body shops can fight and win.”

The appeal dismisses a small claims court magistrate ruling that favored Travelers Insurance’s claim, which alleged that Mike’s Auto Body and All Day & Night Towing were engaging in unfair business practices, challenging their rates and other charges.

“The judge found in our favor, which essentially means that the prior judgments awarded against the body shop and tow company have been vacated and they do not owe Travelers any money,” said Jordan J. Rodrigues, the attorney for the two automotive businesses.

In the end, this judge found the shops’ rates to be justified, explained Rodrigues.

“We were vindicated as the judge found our rates to be fair and not unjustified,” Rodrigues said. “The shops did their work and are entitled to be paid for the services rendered.

“It’s kind of like a David versus Goliath mentality — a billion-dollar insurance company putting all this pressure on the small business. A lot of times, these businesses get letters in the mail from insurers requesting refunds or threatening to sue for triple damages and attorney fees. Nine times out of 10, these small shops probably cave and give in. I’d like to think that maybe this win will put the brakes on that practice.”

For more information on AASP/MA, visit aaspma.org.

You May Also Like

NORTHEAST 2024 to Feature Mike Anderson, Dave Kindig, David Luehr and More

Kindig, Anderson and Luehr are just some of the collision industry celebrities who will be at the NORTHEAST Show March 15-17, 2024.

The Alliance of Automotive Service Providers of New Jersey (AASP/NJ) is gearing up for another exciting NORTHEAST Automotive Services Show March 15-17, 2024 at the Meadowlands Exposition Center in Secaucus, N.J.

Although the show is scheduled for March 15-17, attendees will also want to mark their calendars for March 14 since AASP/NJ is enhancing its educational offerings by adding a full-day "Know Your Numbers" workshop on Thursday with David Luehr (Elite Body Shop Solutions). The NORTHEAST 2024 educational slate will kick off early Friday morning with the first-ever Collision Advice NORTHEAST Workshop series, featuring industry icon Mike Anderson and his team of expert speakers.

CIECA to Hold Webinar on Top Collision Industry Trends

The webinar, “Top Collision Industry Trends to Watch in 2024”, is scheduled for Thursday, Jan. 25 at 2 p.m. EST.

Oklahoma Auto Body Association to Host Trade Show

The trade show and education forum will take place Feb. 2-3, 2024 at the Cox Business Center in Tulsa, Okla. 

CCA Announces 2024 Tool Grant Initiative

This grant is tailored for individuals dedicated to pursuing a career in the collision repair industry, offering crucial assistance to kickstart their journey.

CIECA Reactivates Vehicle Damage and Imaging/Estimating Committee

The committee will be chaired by CIECA Past Chair Phil Martinez, principal technical consultant at Mitchell International, an Enlyte Company.

Other Posts

NABC Donates Recycled Ride to Deserving Georgia Woman

The NABC, along with Travelers and Classic Collision, recently donated a refurbished vehicle to a deserving Tucker, Ga., woman.

Auto Care Association Launches Aftermarket Essentials Online Course

The Aftermarket Essentials course will take the participant on an exciting journey exploring the inner workings of the vast auto care ecosystem in an easy-to-learn setting at the user’s own pace.

Anthony Trama Inducted into AASP/NJ’s Hall of Fame

Trama is a retired shop owner and longtime supporter and board member of the AASP/NJ.

CIECA Announces 1Source ADAS as New Corporate Member

1Source ADAS provides ADAS software that generates a post-repair report identifying needed calibrations based on a collision repair estimate.