Ask the Expert: Is It Illegal to Deviate from an Insurer's Estimate?

Is It Illegal to Deviate from an Insurer’s Estimate?

If an insurer pays a customer to do certain repairs and the customer doesn’t want certain things done, is it illegal for the collision repairer to not repair or replace something the insurer has paid for?


If an insurer pays a customer to do certain repairs and the customer doesn’t want certain things done, is it illegal for the collision repairer to not repair or replace something the insurer has paid for?

Thank you for your question, and I believe the answer is…NO!

Unless there are any state laws and/or regulations to the contrary, it’s generally understood that once the insurer pays to indemnify the consumer (policyholder or third-party claimant), the consumer may use those funds however they deem appropriate…or not use them for repairs at all. It would be no different than if an at-fault party was to pay their victim in cash for the damages they caused.

Here are some scenarios to help illustrate my point:

Let’s say you prepare an estimate/blue-print for a proper and thorough repair and the insurer pays it in full and your customer elects to not do the paint work as they’re saving their money to one day get an overall paint job. Have they or the repairer done anything wrong?

The customer owns a Jeep and ask that you not replace their front bumper as they intend to add a custom bumper and winch and want the insurance money for the aftermarket one he wants. Have they or the repairer done anything wrong?

You prepare a full and thorough blueprint and the insurer pays it in full. The customer, however, decides to not get it repaired and instead trades their vehicle in as damaged and uses the insurance proceeds toward a replacement vehicle. Has he or you done anything wrong?

I believe the answer to each scenario is, “No, of course not.”

Once an insurer pays to indemnify the consumer, the consumer may then do as they wish with the claim proceeds. It’s the consumer’s monies to do with as they wish. The vehicle owner’s insurer, should they choose to, may then terminate the policy because the damages were not repaired and the insurable risk is no longer desirable to them.

The only time this may not be accurate is if and when the customer has a lienholder and the lienholder’s name is included on the insurer’s payment draft. The lienholder will want the vehicle fixed to ensure its value remains intact to ensure the buyer doesn’t spend the proceeds on other things and then lose interest in the damaged vehicle, stop making payments and allow it to be repossessed. The lienholder will want to retain the vehicle’s value (and their collateral) until their loan is paid in full.

Remember, too, that under most situations a body shop (unless a DRP) has no legal or fiduciary duty to the insurer. The only interaction a collision repairer should have with the insurer is when it pertains to the repair and when it’s in the best interest of the customer/consumer.

Note: Collision repairers should not deviate from the authorized repair estimate of record unless the customer is notified and approves the deviation/change. When this takes place, it should be well documented and be clearly and accurately noted on the final invoice.

Remember, “It’s not about doing one thing 100 percent better, it’s about doing 100 things one percent better…consistently.”

You May Also Like

Three Generations Keep Trains Running on Time at CARSTAR Jacobus

CARSTAR Jacobus Founder Jerry Jacobus and son Dave share a passion for collision repair and also model railroading.

When Dave Jacobus’ father opened his automobile repair shop in Vancouver, Wash., in 1976, he never dreamed that his son and grandson would still be running it nearly 50 years later. But everything is on track for CARSTAR Jacobus as they plan for a new greenfield location and stoke the engines for Jacobus’ son, Justin, to keep the trains running on time into the next half-century.

Auto Body Repair: The Right Way, the Wrong Way and Another Way

In a perfect world, every repairer would make the right decisions in every repair, but we don’t live in a perfect world.

The Digital Blitz

We talk so much about how much collision repair is changing, but so is the world of media!

Auto Body Shops: Building a Foundation for the New Year

For the new year, it’s important to conduct a thorough audit of your finances to look for areas of opportunity and things to change.

Auto Body Consolidation Update: There’s a New Buyer in Town

The good news for shops that want to sell but do not fit a consolidator’s
profile is that there is a fresh pool of new buyers.

Other Posts

Is Your Auto Body Shop a Hobby … or a Business?

So you want to provide safe and properly repair vehicles to your customers … even at a financial loss?

BodyShop Business 2023 Executives of the Year

Greg Solesbee was named the Single-Shop Executive of the Year, and Charlie Drake was named the Multi-Shop Executive of the Year.

This Could Be Your Last Text

A sign I saw on the highway that said “This Could Be Your Last Text” reminded me of my son’s recent car wreck.

SUNY Morrisville Auto Body Program Makes Students, Cars Shine 

A 1997 Mustang Cobra is getting the chance to shine again, thanks to students in Alexander Graf’s auto body technology classes.