Auto Insurers Score Another Victory in Antitrust Litigation

Auto Insurers Score Another Victory in Auto Body Shop Antitrust Litigation

Judge in auto body antitrust case dismisses body shops' antitrust claims, but provides them with leave to amend their antitrust claims and refile them when they again amend their complaint.

Capitol-buildingOn Aug. 17th, United States District Judge Greg Presnell (M.D. Fla.) handed the auto insurer defendants in the In re Auto Body Antitrust Litigation another significant victory, confirming a “Report and Recommendation” by Magistrate Judge Thomas Smith that recommended that plaintiffs’ antitrust claims be dismissed. And, while the plaintiffs have been granted leave to amend their antitrust claims, the plaintiffs’ decision not to object to Magistrate Smith’s recommendation that the antitrust claims be dismissed (albeit without prejudice) suggests, according to Baker Donelson Bearman, Caldwell & Berkowitz, PC, that the plaintiffs “may be losing enthusiasm for their antitrust claims and may have decided to focus going forward on the non-antitrust claims that they have also raised in the litigation.”

The action was initiated by the filing of a single action by A&E Auto Body in federal court in the Middle District of Florida (A&E Auto Body v. 21st Century Centennial Insurance Co.), but quickly became a multi-district litigation proceeding after similar actions were filed by auto body shops in several states. The actions all center upon the claim that many of the nation’s leading auto insurers conspired to reduce rates for the repair of damaged vehicles and to steer insureds away from plaintiffs’ shops, after plaintiffs refused to accept lower reimbursement rates for their services. All of the cases were consolidated before Judge Presnell in late 2014, and in early 2015 the court dismissed the plaintiffs’ claims in the A&E case, with leave to amend.

In February of 2015, plaintiffs in the consolidated cases filed an omnibus Amended Complaint, seeking to address the deficiencies in the A&E complaint that Judge Presnell had identified in dismissing that initial complaint. The auto insurers moved to dismiss the Amended Complaint as well, arguing that the new complaint was no less infirm than the A&E complaint had been.

In June, Magistrate Judge Thomas Smith issued a “Report and Recommendation” in the case, recommending to Judge Presnell that the plaintiffs’ antitrust claims (and many of their other claims as well) should be dismissed without prejudice. Magistrate Smith noted that the plaintiffs’ allegations were quite similar to those in the A&E case, and that they failed for the same reasons. With respect to the antitrust allegations, Magistrate Smith concluded that the plaintiffs had again failed to allege sufficient facts to support their claim of unlawful agreement, principally relying upon unacceptable “group pleading” allegations and conclusory allegations rather than facts to support their claims.

Specifically, in recommending dismissal of the antitrust claims, Magistrate Smith stated, “The Court’s reasoning in dismissing the antitrust claims in [A&E] applies with equal force here. Therefore, I recommend that plaintiffs’ claims for price fixing and group boycotts in violation of the Sherman Act be dismissed.”

While the plaintiffs filed a 45-page brief objecting to Magistrate Smith’s “Report,” they did not challenge Magistrate Smith’s recommendation that their antitrust claims be dismissed. Under the circumstances, Judge Presnell’s adoption of Magistrate Smith’s Report on the antitrust issue was, according to Baker Donelson Bearman, Caldwell & Berkowitz, “unsurprising, but welcome news for the auto insurer defendants.” Judge Presnell did, however, provide the plaintiffs with leave to amend their antitrust claims and refile them when they again amend their complaint. Whether the plaintiffs will accept that invitation, or move forward only with their various tort claims, remains to be seen. However, as of now, it appears that the insurers have defeated the plaintiffs’ antitrust claims, in a series of rulings that Baker Donelson Bearman, Caldwell & Berkowitz says insurers across the country are “likely applauding.”

You May Also Like

Crash Champions Opens 25th Ohio Location

Crash Champions announced it has opened a new shop in Avon, Ohio, its 25th location in the Buckeye State.

Crash Champions announced another step in the organization's ongoing strategic national growth plan by opening its 25th Ohio location. The collision repair center, located at 38401 Chester Road in Avon, Ohio, officially opened on March 20th.

“We’re thrilled to continue expanding the Crash Champions team across Ohio,” said Matt Ebert, founder and CEO of Crash Champions. “Since first expanding to the area in 2020, Crash Champions has made it our mission to deliver high-quality collision repair service while also engaging with local communities. The opening of our Avon repair center is part of this important effort. We look forward to investing in this team and providing our services to local customers and business partners.” 

Milton Industries Acquires Steck Manufacturing

Milton extends tool offerings in automotive repair, collision repair, lockout and towing markets.

ASE Announces Keynote for 2023 Instructor Training Conference

Renowned speaker and best-selling author Eric Chester will focus on helping to make sure graduates of automotive educational programs succeed in their careers.

Classic Collision Expands in Florida

Classic Collision has announced the acquisition of Auto Tech Collision Center in East Lakeland, Fla.

Gift of $500K to Fund New Professorship at Northwood University

The Subaru of New England Professor of Automotive Strategy will enhance student learning and elevate Northwood University’s distinctiveness.

Other Posts

VA, NC Commissioners of Insurance to Present at SCRS Meeting

North Carolina Commissioner of Insurance Mike Causey and Virginia Commissioner of Insurance Scott White will highlight the activities their offices engage in to serve auto insurance consumers.

Crash Champions Donates Recycled Ride to Single Mother

Crash Champions recently restored and donated a Hyundai Elantra to a Springfield, Mo., single mother in need as part of the Recycled Rides program.

CCCR to Address Unpaid Administrative Time

According to a recent survey, unpaid administrative time, material costs and repair versus replace are the top three issues facing Canadian collision repairers.

Videos of the Week

Video spotlight for the week of March 13.