Class Action Suit Filed Against State Farm for Violation of "Make Whole Rule" - BodyShop Business

Class Action Suit Filed Against State Farm for Violation of “Make Whole Rule”

A class action lawsuit was filed today in United States Federal Court,
Central District, alleging that State Farm is enriching itself with
payments rightfully belonging to its insureds in violation of
California law, particularly the "Make Whole Rule."

When State Farm policyholder Stuart Chandler of Fresno, Calif., was
rear-ended, his personal automobile insurance policy entitled him to a
rental car while his car was being fixed. Under Chandler’s auto policy,
State Farm paid 80 percent of the $317.45. Chandler was charged for his
rental car, leaving Chandler to pay 20 percent, or $63.49, in
out-of-pocket expenses.

State Farm then went to the other party’s insurance company to collect
the money it had paid out to Chandler. That insurance company
reimbursed State Farm $70 for the rental car. The complaint alleges
that pursuant to California’s "Make Whole Rule," State Farm should have
refunded Chandler from that amount the $63.49 for out-of-pocket
expenses he incurred before it could retain any of those funds for
itself. Instead, the complaint alleges, State Farm kept the full amount
for itself, ignoring the fact that Chandler has not been fully
compensated for his loss as required by law.

"California common law provides that when a policyholder suffers a
loss from a car accident, the policyholder must be reimbursed for all
of his losses before State Farm has a right to reimbursement for any
money it paid out under its policy," says Long Beach, Calif. plaintiff
attorney Stephen M. Garcia of The Garcia Law Firm.

This rule is known as the "Make Whole Rule," and is a common law
exception to an insurance company’s subrogation right. The "Make Whole
Rule" basically states that before any of the recovery is allocated to
the insurer, the insured who suffered the loss must be fully
compensated for all the elements of damages, not just those for which
the insurer has indemnified the policyholder.

According to State Farm’s Web site, the company insures more cars
any other insurer in the United States and handled 12.3 million total
claims in 2007.

"Mr. Chandler’s case is just $63 and change," says Garcia. "Imagine $63
times the tens of thousands of claims State Farm handles in California
alone. We believe that State Farm is enriching itself with money that
rightfully belongs to its policyholders."

You May Also Like

CIF Announces LKQ Corp. as Repeat Annual Donor

LKQ Corp. committed again to the CIF Annual Donor Program, marking their third consecutive donation at the First Responder tier.

The Collision Industry Foundation (CIF) announced that LKQ Corp. committed again to the CIF Annual Donor Program. This marks the third consecutive donation at the First Responder (highest) tier.

Introduced in 2021, the Annual Donor Program was designed to bring needed recurring resources to the foundation so it can deliver on its mission to "answer the call" when those in the industry have been impacted by catastrophic events such as wildfires, hurricanes, flooding or COVID.

Car ADAS Adds Integrations and Support Manager

In his new role, Nate Thomsen will help open new calibration centers and support licensees to ensure their success.

Wren’s Collision Centers Opens 14th Location in Georgia

Wren’s Collision Centers announced the grand opening of its 14th location in the historic district of Roswell, Ga.

Classic Collision Adds Three New Locations in Southeast Florida

Classic Collision has acquired Empire Auto Body in Pompano Beach, Factory Certified Collision in Oakland Park and Southeast Collision Center in Boca Raton, Fla.

McBride Auto Body: Established in 1937

Joseph Carioti immigrated from Italy to the U.S. in 1910 and founded McBride Auto Body in 1937.

Other Posts

Events of the Week

Recent event announcements on

People on the Move

Recent personnel news that has appeared on

Top 5 Stories of the Week

A recap of the top five stories on during the week of Feb. 12.

ASA Calls on Oklahoma Legislature to Oppose S.B. 1853

ASA says the legislation would make it harder for auto repair businesses to return a vehicle to safe operating condition by imposing a litany of price mandates and other unfair rules.