Judge Dismisses False-Arrest Lawsuit Against Geico

Judge Dismisses False-Arrest Lawsuit Against GEICO

After GEICO paid her for the total loss of her vehicle, Rosinda Matute-Castellanos played a cat-and-mouse game with GEICO and salvage company Insurance Auto Auctions, neither of which was able to locate the vehicle on multiple occasions.

A federal judge has dismissed a Georgia woman’s false-arrest lawsuit against GEICO.

After being involved in a March 2012 collision with a GEICO-insured driver, Rosinda Matute-Castellanos of Atlanta agreed to sign title of her car over to GEICO, which cut her a check for the total loss of the vehicle.

However, according to court documents, Matute-Castellanos played a cat-and-mouse game with GEICO and salvage company Insurance Auto Auctions, neither of which was able to locate the vehicle on multiple occasions.

GEICO eventually filed a police report, and the Chamblee Police Department assigned Det. Chris Newberry to investigate.

“Based on inconsistencies in [Matute-Castellanos’s] report, her delay in reporting the vehicle stolen, her failure to return Newberry’s calls and the frequent relocation of the vehicle, Newberry suspected [Matute-Castellanos] had ‘sold the vehicle and reported her vehicle stolen,’” Judge Thomas Thrash Jr. of the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Georgia explained in his summary judgment.

Based on Newberry’s findings, the DeKalb County Magistrate Court issued a warrant for her arrest on July 24, 2012.

Matute-Castellanos was arrested on March 8, 2014. However, the charges were dropped after the state solicitor determined that the statute of limitations had expired.

In October 2016, Rosinda Matute-Castellanos filed a lawsuit against GEICO, alleging claims of false arrest and malicious prosecution, as well as negligent hiring, training and supervision.

In his summary judgment, Thrash noted that her lawsuit failed to provide that GEICO – specifically Mike Mitchell of the insurer’s Special Investigations Unit, who had referred the matter to police – acted with malice in deciding to prosecute Matute-Castellanos.

“There is nothing in the record to indicate that GEICO acted with malice in prosecuting [Matute-Castellanos] for the concealment of property,” Thrash wrote. “Mitchell never knew [Matute-Castellanos] personally, and in fact never had the opportunity to meet with or communicate with [her] at all, despite his best efforts to do so. All the evidence on the record indicates that Mitchell contacted the police solely because of the results of his investigation, not because of any personal hostility.”

Thrash also concluded that Matute-Castellanos failed to prove her assertion that GEICO was “negligent in hiring, training and supervising the staff in the pickup and investigation of the recovery of vehicles and reporting them to the state.”

“[Matute-Castellanos] has produced no evidence whatsoever to suggest that there have been any previous incidents similar to those alleged in this case,” Thrash wrote. “Nor has [she] produced any evidence showing that GEICO knew or should have known such incidents occurred even if they did.”

Attorney Craig Terrett of Cruser, Mitchell, Novitz, Sanchez, Gaston & Zimet, who defended the case with partner J. Robb Cruser, told PropertyCasualty360.com that this was “a mess of a case.”

“This was definitely the right result,” Terrett told the website.

You May Also Like

Repairify, Autel Announce New Initiatives for 2024

In Q1 2024, Autel and Repairify will continue to enhance the value of their combined services for their users through various planned releases.

Repairify, Inc., a portfolio company of Kinderhook Industries, LLC, and Autel U.S., a wholly-owned subsidiary of Autel Intelligent Technology Corp., Ltd., are focusing on key partnership advances made this year and announcing bold initiatives for 2024. 

Repairify and Autel have enhanced the efficiency of the collision and glass repair shop workflow and documentation process by seamlessly integrating Repairify’s remote services and authentic OEM tool scans into the Autel Remote Expert platform. This integration, now available on Autel MaxiSYS Ultra series tablets and MaxiFlash XLink standalone communication devices, increases efficiency by reducing the number of in-shop tools needed to support vehicle diagnostics, calibrations and programming events.

GCIA December Meeting to Feature Mike Anderson

Anderson will give a talk titled “Be Extraordinary” at the Georgia Collision Industry Association meeting on Dec. 13.

Central PA I-CAR Holding Bingo Fundraiser

The fundraiser, which will be held Jan. 20, 2024 from 1-5 p.m., will benefit Central Pennsylvania area collision programs.

NABC Forms Changing and Saving Lives Foundation

The Changing and Saving Lives Foundation, a 501(c)3 organization, was founded to provide support and assistance to families in need, military members, veterans and first responders.

Precision Diagnostics Approved for Ford’s Collision & Glass Program

Madison, Wis.-based Precision Diagnostics recently earned approval as an authorized service partner on Ford’s Collision & Glass Certification program for ADAS calibrations.

Other Posts

TechForce Foundation Names New Chief Growth Officer

As chief growth officer, Jennifer Bergeron brings over 20 years of experience in technical education and organizational management to TechForce.

CREF Selected for LKQ Holiday Vote Fundraiser

The Collision Repair Education Foundation (CREF) was selected as one of the 10 participation charities in the LKQ Cares Holiday Vote fundraiser for this year.

Ford Approves AirPro Diagnostics for Collision, Glass Programs

AirPro Diagnostics announced that Ford has approved AirPro as a diagnostics and calibrations provider to ensure a complete and safe repair.

ASA Applauds Regulatory Proposal that Excludes Collision Repairers

The proposal would have increased required reporting under a revised Air Emissions Reporting Requirements (AERR) regulation.