Maryland Collision Repairer Wins Short-Pay Lawsuit Against GEICO - BodyShop Business

Maryland Collision Repairer Wins Short-Pay Lawsuit Against GEICO

Insurer must pay $392.95 in repair costs on behalf of its policyholder.

A Maryland body shop owner has won a short-pay lawsuit he filed against GEICO on behalf of a customer.

Mark Schaech, co-owner of Mark’s Body Shop of Baltimore, filed the suit against GEICO due to the insurer’s refusal to pay $392.95 in repair costs on behalf of its policyholder. The underpayments included: degreasing vehicle prior to repair; feather, prime and block repaired panels; clean vehicle for delivery; clear OBD fault codes; reset electronics (recorded settings); mask for primer; and overhaul door handle for refinishing.

“We offer exceptional quality and service to our customers, and to continue to do so without being properly compensated is simply unreasonable and unsustainable," said Schaech. "While my father (partner) and I would rather avoid having to take such legal actions, something had to be done as the insurer’s efforts to underpay our customers continued to increase. I felt like that guy in the movie Network where he stuck his head out the window and yelled, ‘I’m mad as hell and I’m not taking this anymore!’

“While Maryland does not allow the recovery of legal fees to the prevailing parties in such issues, we couldn’t allow that to be a deterrent in our being able to properly serve our customers and our employees. Insurers have continued cutting their costs while our costs for labor, materials and overhead have steadily increased. The only way we could survive was to either concede to the underpayments and cut our quality of materials and labor…or push back. We found short-pay litigation necessary to stop the insurer’s practice of underpaying our customers and to enable us to provide the quality repairs that earn our customers (and their referrals) for life."

Schaech credited a free legal seminar in Florida hosted by Barrett Smith of Auto Damage Experts, Ray Gunder of Gunder’s Auto Center and Gunder’s attorney, Brent Geohagan, with motivating him and giving him the information he needed to take action.

"That was a turning point for us. To hear Ray talk about how he knew that if he hadn’t done something he would be out of business struck a chord in me, and I knew then that I, too, needed to do something or we would lose our business," Schaech said. "Ray gave much credit to his success in having a great support team in Barrett as his consultant and Brent as his legal counsel.”

You May Also Like

PPG Extends Partnerships with Indianapolis Motor Speedway, INDYCAR, Team Penske

The agreement also makes PPG the entitlement sponsor of the Brickyard 400 NASCAR CUP series race, which takes place at the IMS.

PPG announced that it has extended its partnerships with the Indianapolis Motor Speedway (IMS), INDYCAR and Team Penske through 2029. The agreement also makes PPG the entitlement sponsor of the Brickyard 400 NASCAR CUP series race, which takes place at the IMS.

“We are excited to build upon our extensive history with Team Penske, INDYCAR and IMS,” said Tim Knavish, chairman and CEO of PPG. “To be able to expand and strengthen these relationships speaks to the commitment and success we’ve had together. I look forward to the seeing the PPG name on Team Penske cars and at the Brickyard 400 for years to come.”

Women in Auto Care Achieves Record-Breaking Scholarship Distribution

Approximately 81 awards totaling $425,000 were distributed to female students across the U.S. interested in pursuing careers in the automotive aftermarket.

Brian Cruickshank Elected as CAWA’s 2025 Secretary to Board of Directors

Cruickshank is a partner at Schwartz Advisors, an aftermarket-focused M&A advisory firm.

People on the Move

Recent personnel news that has appeared on bodyshopbusiness.com.

Matt Daigle Joins SEMA’s Public and Government Affairs Team

Daigle is a seasoned communicator with more than 20 years of experience and leadership in advocacy and member communications.

Other Posts
Consolidator Report

Consolidation news from the week of July 15.

Top 5 Stories of the Week

A recap of the top five stories on bodyshopbusiness.com during the week of July 15.

PPG Recognized as Best Place to Work for Disability Inclusion

This is the third consecutive year PPG has earned this recognition from the Disability Quality Index.

NABC Donates Recycled Rides to Denver-Area Military Families

The NABC, GEICO, Allstate and Crash Champions recently donated refurbished vehicles to two military families in the Colorado State Capitol.