New Jersey Body Shop Owner Turns Down Meeting with State Farm on Paint and Materials - BodyShop Business

New Jersey Body Shop Owner Turns Down Meeting with State Farm on Paint and Materials

Believes insurer should be able to answer in writing how they can determine paint material rate based on "yes or no" question in their survey.

Don Harvey of International Collision Service in Englewood, New Jersey, wrote a letter to State Farm CEO Ed Rust in February 2012 to address what he felt was an inadequate paint and materials reimbursement rate. Despite State Farm responding to his queries, Harvey says he still hasn’t received a satisfactory answer to how the reimbursement rate was determined from a “yes or no” question on the insurer’s survey. The yes or no question on the survey he referred to is, "Do you use an automated paint and materials rate calculator?"

In response to another letter Harvey wrote dated July 10, State Farm stated that it believed the best opportunity to provide him with a more complete understanding of their survey was to facilitate a one-on-one discussion between him and their estimatics leadership in New Jersey. Harvey first replied by stating, "It seems State Farm is ‘dancing’ around these issues as this now is the fourth letter and yet no answers to either the material reimbursement or the explanation on how the rate got determined from a yes or no question on State Farm’s survey."

In a letter dated August 21, Harvey thanked them for the invite but turned it down.

“My concerns as a member of the New Jersey auto body community is an answer to how a paint material rate has been determined from State Farm’s ‘survey’ when a yes or no is the only option,” said Harvey. “This clearly is a question that can be answered in writing and doesn’t require a one-on-one meeting to address.” 

More information:

New Jersey Body Shop Owner Queries State Farm CEO Again on Paint & Materials

You May Also Like

SEMA Sponsors ZEV Conversion Rebate Bill in California

Senate Bill 301 would create a financial rebate program for converting gas and diesel-powered motor vehicles into zero-emissions-vehicles.

Senator Anthony J. Portantino (D-Burbank) recently introduced Senate Bill 301, a bill sponsored by the Specialty Equipment Market Association (SEMA) to create a financial rebate program for converting gas and diesel-powered motor vehicles into zero-emissions-vehicles (ZEVs). The legislation will allow California to support small businesses and maintain its rich car culture, while assisting consumers that want to convert their vehicles to cleaner engines. 

Top 5 Stories of the Week

A recap of the top five stories on during the week of Jan. 30.

Consolidator Report

Consolidation news from the week of Jan. 30.

Association News

The latest association news on

NGK/NTK, Autel Create Diagnostic Webinar Series

NGK Spark Plugs (U.S.A.), Inc., and Autel U.S. have again joined forces to create diagnostic webinar sessions.

Other Posts

CARSTAR Ranked First Again in Collision by Entrepreneur

CARSTAR has been ranked number one in the collision repair category among the top franchises in Entrepreneur magazine’s 2023 Franchise 500.

Classic Collision Announces Executive Promotions

Classic Collision has announced the promotion of Alexander Brinkman and Cody Johnson to vice president of mergers and acquisitions.

CIECA Announces 2023 Board of Trustees Officers

The Collision Industry Electronic Commerce Association announced that its board of trustees has elected new officers for 2023.

ASE Partners with Michael Lewis for IMSA Racing Series

ASE will sponsor International Motor Sports Association driver Michael Lewis for the 2023 season.