North State Custom Lawsuit Against Progressive Moves Forward - BodyShop Business

North State Custom Lawsuit Against Progressive Moves Forward

Ruling in favor of New York shop paves way for deceptive acts and practices claims against insurers that steer policyholders to shops outside their networks.

North State Custom, a Westchester-based auto body shop owned by Greg Coccaro, has emerged victorious in the New York Appellate Division, Second Department, against Progressive and several of its affiliates – paving the way for deceptive acts and practices claims against auto insurance companies that divert policyholders away from repair shops outside their favored networks.   

North State sued Progressive under New York’s deceptive acts and practices statute, General Business Law section 349, for misleading consumers into taking their damaged vehicles away from North State to competing body shops within Progressive’s “network.” North State’s suit alleges that the insurance company coaxed customers away by maligning the shop’s work and pricing.

In North State Autobahn v. Progressive Insurance, the Second Department’s ruling, denying Progressive’s motion for summary judgment and allowing North State’s suit to go forward, confirmed a business’ standing to recover for direct harm caused to it by another business’ deceptive acts and practices – even if that business is a competitor. Justice Robert Miller, writing for a unanimous panel, held that North State’s allegations concerning Progressive’s acts depriving consumers of their choice of body shop satisfied the statute’s requirement that the deceptive acts at issue have an impact on consumers at large. The court further held that the law does not require that North State identify specific consumers who were harmed.

The court also rejected Progressive’s argument that North State’s injury was merely derivative of that of the injured consumers, finding that North State adequately alleged direct harm the instant customers were misled into taking their vehicles to a network shop, regardless of whether such customers ultimately suffered pecuniary injury. The fact that North State was a business competitor and not the consumer in the transaction was held to be irrelevant for purposes of standing under the statute, under which punitive damages and attorneys’ fees are recoverable.

"This is a significant decision that enables businesses to pursue ‘deceptive acts and practices’ claims in business-to-business disputes – even between competitors – that have an impact on consumers at large," said Dennis Artese, a shareholder at Anderson Kill & Olick, the law firm that represented North State. “That’s critically important because it allows well-funded businesses to police deceptive practices where the state attorney general does not, and where individual consumers cannot, because they just do not have the financial means to fight an insurance goliath like Progressive in the legal system.”

Along with Artese, North State was represented by Finley Harckham of Anderson Kill and solo practitioners Anthony Mamo and Richard P. Stone.


More information:

An Analysis of Progressive Insurance vs. North State Custom

North State Custom

You May Also Like

Survey Finds More Body Shops Researching OEM Repair Procedures

The latest “Who Pays for What?” survey indicates that 61% of shops say they’re researching OE procedures on “all” or “most” vehicles.

The latest "Who Pays for What?" survey from Collision Advice and CRASH Network indicates that more than three in five shops (61%) say they're researching automaker repair procedures on “all” or “most” of the vehicles they repair, a nine percentage point gain since 2020.

“It’s still not a high enough percentage, because this must be done every time, but at least awareness of this vital step is increasing,” said Mike Anderson of Collision Advice, who conducts the quarterly surveys with CRASH Network. “OEM information is complex, and can change. I recently wrote an estimate on three of the same year and model of vehicles, but the alignment procedures and battery disconnect procedures were different based on trim levels and engine types.”

Classic Collision Expands into Florida Keys

Classic Collision has announced the acquisition of Cooper’s Paint & Body Shop in Key West, Fla.

People on the Move

Recent personnel news that has appeared on bodyshopbusiness.com.

Consolidator Report

Consolidation news from the week of July 1.

CIECA to Hold Webinar on V2X Technology

The webinar, “Why the Collision Industry Should Be Interested in V2X,” will be held on July 25 at 2 p.m. EST.

Other Posts
Top 5 Stories of the Week

A recap of the top five stories on bodyshopbusiness.com during the week of July 1.

Tint World Expands Texas Footprint with East Houston Location

The National Automotive Styling Centers franchise announced the opening of its 25th store in the state.

GFS Names Platinum Equipment Preferred Refinish Distributor for Illinois

Founded in 2020, Platinum Equipment supplies, installs and services a variety of automotive repair equipment, including paint booths and frame racks.

Global Finishing Solutions, GFC logo
Fix Network to Host 2025 Global Conference in Mexico

The conference will take place April 27-May 1, 2025 at the Dreams Playa Mujeres Golf & Spa Resort in Mexico.