Results of Latest Crash Test by Attorney Todd Tracy Unveiled at Texas Auto Body Trade Show - BodyShop Business

Results of Latest Crash Test by Attorney Todd Tracy Unveiled at Texas Auto Body Trade Show

The results of Attorney Todd Tracy's latest crash test were recently unveiled at the 2018 Texas Auto Body Trade Show in Fort Worth, Texas.
(Left to right) Larry Cernosek (Houston Auto Body Association), John Kopriva (Houston Auto Body Association), Todd Tracy, Kevin Jordan (Burl’s Collision Center), Burl Richards (Auto Body Association of Texas/Burl’s Collision Center), Jerry McNee (Ultimate Collision Repair) and Donald “Trip” Springer (Burl’s Collision Center).
The results of Attorney Todd Tracy’s latest crash test were recently unveiled at the 2018 Texas Auto Body Trade Show in Fort Worth, Texas.
Earlier this year, Tracy commissioned three crash tests of three Honda Fit vehicles using various repair methods and OE and aftermarket parts to determine which vehicle performed the best and protected occupants the most. Tracy is the Texas-based attorney known for his $42 million legal ruling against John Eagle Collision in Dallas. After the results of those tests were revealed, the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety, after analyzing the data, stated that the vehicles still rated as “good” and there was no concern about aftermarket parts.
The new crash test used a 2010 Honda Fit with no prior accidents that was refitted with OEM replacement parts according to the manufacturer’s procedures at Burl’s Collision Center in Henderson, Texas. Tracy then had those same OEM replacement parts replaced with aftermarket parts. Prior to the OEM-specific repairs, the undamaged Honda Fit was thoroughly inspected, measured on a frame machine and pre-repair scanned to check for pre-existing codes. Once the work was completed, Burl’s Collision Center performed a post-repair scan to ensure that no codes were generated during the repair process.
According to Tracy, the test results revealed that the genuine OE parts performed exactly as intended to ensure passenger safety, while the previously crashed vehicle with aftermarket parts installed produced results that Tracy called “total and massive destruction” in critical areas. For example, the driver left femur force on the aftermarket parts-repaired vehicle was 1700 N (newton) but only 397 N (newton) on the vehicle repaired with genuine Honda OEM parts –  a “400 percent difference,” Tracy said. Results of the latest crash test are available at https://goo.gl/epEdFh.
“The biggest takeaway of this presentation is that we’re beginning to define what ‘like, kind and quality’ means,” said Burl Richards, president of the Auto Body Association of Texas and owner of Burl’s Collision Center. “We now have scientific proof that shows vehicles are safer when they’re repaired using OEM parts and OEM procedures. We made major frontal repairs to this vehicle, and its crashworthiness held up and was exactly the same as a new OEM car.”
Jerry McNee of Ultimate Collision Repair, who helped finance this most recent crash test performance at KARCO Engineering in California, added, “Most professional repairers know that aftermarket parts are not the same as OEM parts. However, insurers are willing to twist, turn and use the position statements incorrectly. They make comments like, ‘It’s just a fender,’ ‘It’s in their policy’ and ‘LKQ parts are the same.’ They’re dictating what they’re paying for to unjustly enrich themselves, but numbers and test results don’t lie. This OEM-repaired car fared exactly like the undamaged Honda Fit. When there is a 400 to 800 percent difference in the results between the OEM-repaired car, the aftermarket-repaired car and the improperly repaired car, it’s staggering. This could be the difference between broken bones, permanent injuries, life or death – or, in the Honda Fit case, people trapped helplessly while their vehicle is on fire. Mr. Insurance Company, please tell me how these parts are the same and ‘like kind and quality.’ Show me the proof! Would you put your kids in an improperly repaired car? Do you feel lucky? Your odds are 400 to 800 percent.”
In addition to McNee, Burl’s Collision Center and the Houston Auto Body Association, financial contributors to the latest crash test include Dominic and Mario Martino of Gold Coast Auto Body in Chicago and John Mosley of Clinton Body Shop in Mississippi.
“By dictating improper vehicle repairs for decades, insurance companies have killed thousands of customers who were driving around in time bombs,” said Tracy. “Your industry has to work together with politicians and state agencies so that insurance companies stop jeopardizing family safety.”
You May Also Like

Survey Finds More Body Shops Researching OEM Repair Procedures

The latest “Who Pays for What?” survey indicates that 61% of shops say they’re researching OE procedures on “all” or “most” vehicles.

The latest "Who Pays for What?" survey from Collision Advice and CRASH Network indicates that more than three in five shops (61%) say they're researching automaker repair procedures on “all” or “most” of the vehicles they repair, a nine percentage point gain since 2020.

“It’s still not a high enough percentage, because this must be done every time, but at least awareness of this vital step is increasing,” said Mike Anderson of Collision Advice, who conducts the quarterly surveys with CRASH Network. “OEM information is complex, and can change. I recently wrote an estimate on three of the same year and model of vehicles, but the alignment procedures and battery disconnect procedures were different based on trim levels and engine types.”

Classic Collision Expands into Florida Keys

Classic Collision has announced the acquisition of Cooper’s Paint & Body Shop in Key West, Fla.

People on the Move

Recent personnel news that has appeared on bodyshopbusiness.com.

Consolidator Report

Consolidation news from the week of July 1.

CIECA to Hold Webinar on V2X Technology

The webinar, “Why the Collision Industry Should Be Interested in V2X,” will be held on July 25 at 2 p.m. EST.

Other Posts
Top 5 Stories of the Week

A recap of the top five stories on bodyshopbusiness.com during the week of July 1.

Tint World Expands Texas Footprint with East Houston Location

The National Automotive Styling Centers franchise announced the opening of its 25th store in the state.

GFS Names Platinum Equipment Preferred Refinish Distributor for Illinois

Founded in 2020, Platinum Equipment supplies, installs and services a variety of automotive repair equipment, including paint booths and frame racks.

Global Finishing Solutions, GFC logo
Fix Network to Host 2025 Global Conference in Mexico

The conference will take place April 27-May 1, 2025 at the Dreams Playa Mujeres Golf & Spa Resort in Mexico.