Smaller and Regional Auto Insurers Get Top Grades from Collision Repairers

Smaller, Regional Auto Insurers Get Top Grades from Repairers

According to the 2021 CRASH Network Insurer Report Card, collision repairers continue to see smaller auto insurers outpacing the 10 largest insurers.

Collision repairers continue to see smaller auto insurers outpacing the 10 largest insurers in terms of working to ensure quality repairs and customer service, according to the findings of the 2021 CRASH Network “Insurer Report Card.”

Chubb, Erie Insurance, Michigan Farm Bureau and North Carolina Farm Bureau each earned an overall grade of A- or higher from shops evaluating the insurers in terms of how well each company’s “policies, attitude and payment practices ensure quality repairs and customer service for motorists.”

More than 1,100 individual shops around the country each graded as many as 30 different insurance companies in their state. In all, this year’s Insurer Report Card includes grades for 75 insurance companies.

“Consumers go a decade, on average, without interacting with their insurance company’s claims department, but collision repairers do so every day,” said John Yoswick of CRASH Network. “That gives shops meaningful perspective on which companies do the best job taking care of policyholders – and which ones have some room for improvement. We see the Insurer Report Card providing useful information for drivers as they consider which insurer to choose.”

None of the 10 largest auto insurers – the companies most familiar to consumers thanks to the billions of dollars those insurers spend on marketing – received an overall grade higher than a C+ from shops.

“Some of the highest-graded insurers sell policies in only a limited number of states, but most consumers will find at least one or two insurers among the 15 highest-graded who offer auto insurance policies in their state,” said Yoswick.

Shops participating in the Insurer Report Card said those highest-graded insurers place an emphasis on:

  • “Repairing vehicles properly”
  • “Following the auto manufacturers’ guidelines”
  • “Keeping their customers’ best interests paramount”

They criticized the insurers they gave lower grades, using such phrases such as:

  • “Cares more about cost than quality of the repair”
  • “Pressures us to use cheap, low-quality parts
  • “Slow claims process”
  • “Inexperienced adjusters”

The list of highest-graded insurers in 2021 was remarkably consistent with last year’s findings; among the 15 highest-graded insurers in this year’s Insurer Report Card, 10 were in the Top 15 last year as well.

A free report with the 2021 “Insurer Report Card” findings can be downloaded here.

You May Also Like

Axalta Announces Partnership with Solera

Axalta customers will now be able to estimate their CO2 emissions per repair while considering repair methods, paint application process and drying conditions.

Axalta announced it has partnered with Solera, whereby Axalta's conventional and Fast Cure Low Energy (FCLE) refinish paint systems will be integrated into Solera’s Sustainable Estimatics platform, enabling Axalta customers to estimate their CO2 emissions per repair while considering repair methods (repair versus replace), paint application process and drying conditions.

CTHS Auto Collision Students Dominate UTI Top Tech Challenge

Auto Collision students at Dr. Kirk Lewis Career and Technical High School placed in six of the top 10 spots at the recent UTI Top Tech Challenge competition.

PPG to Build New Paint and Coatings Manufacturing Facility in Tennessee

The new plant is part of PPG’s planned $300 million investment in advanced manufacturing in North America to support increased demand for paints and coatings in the automotive industry.

CIF Announces Sherwin-Williams as Repeat Annual Donor

This marks Sherwin-Williams’ third consecutive donation at the Urgent Care tier.

Florida Maaco Transfers Ownership to Longtime Industry Veterans

Maaco announced that Maaco Longwood in Longwood, Fla., has transferred ownership from Elimu Kajunju to Justin DePasquale and Pete Huber.

Other Posts

AirPro Diagnostics Named Preferred Supplier for Fix Network

AirPro Diagnostics announced it has entered into an agreement with Fix Network to supply its franchisees with diagnostics and ADAS calibrations technologies.

ASE Spring Testing Underway, Deadline June 30

Those who register by June 30 will have 90 days to schedule an appointment to take their selected ASE tests.

Billions and Billions: Private Equity Investments in Collision Repair Surge 

In the last five months, more than $9 billion in capital has been invested into the collision repair industry by private equity firms.

ASE Offers Tool Kit for Auto Service Professionals Month

The online ASE Tool Kit gives repair shops, parts suppliers and industry organizations access to ASE marketing assets for use in their own communications.