Three-C Body Shops File Lawsuit Against At-Fault Driver

Three-C Body Shops Files Lawsuit Against At-Fault Driver

Suit filed due to Allstate's alleged failure and refusal to provide a Three-C Body Shop customer full payment for numerous reasonable and necessary charges for processes and materials.

On behalf of their customer, Three-C Body Shops has filed suit against the at-fault party due to their insurance company’s denials and underpayments.

The complaint was filed in the Municipal Court of Franklin County in Ohio against Caleb Brickey due to Brickey’s insurer’s (Allstate) failure and refusal to provide a Three-C Body Shop customer full payment for numerous reasonable and necessary charges for processes and materials.

The issues stemmed from an auto accident in which the at-fault party was negligent and admitted liability for damages to Three-C Body Shop’s customer’s 2005 Jeep Liberty.

Three-C submitted their estimate to the at-fault party’s insurer and, after four supplemental attempts to attain the full and proper compensation, proceeded, at the direction of their customer, with the recommended and proper repair.

The final cost of the authorized repair was $5,687.83. Allstate tendered the underpayment of $3,585.43 toward the repair, leaving a difference and deficit of $2,102.40 of which Three-C has incurred and is now seeking recovery on their own behalf.

The lawsuit seeks full payment to Three-C of the difference plus costs, expenses, attorney fees, prejudgment and post-judgment interest.

“Up to now, many repairers have found that to properly meet their customer’s needs and expectations, it is necessary to make a proper and thorough repair and take an Assignment of Proceeds and, through ensuing litigation, seek recovery against their customer’s own insurers by an assignment contract clause and a Power of Attorney signed by the customer,” said Bob Juniper, second-generation president and owner of Three-C. “This matter involves a third-party claimant seeking recompense for the insurer’s denials and underpayments directly from the at-fault party. This process exposes the insurer’s poor behavior to their policyholder and places the at-fault party in a position of vulnerability and exposes them to liabilities – liabilities they expected their own insurer to shield them from. Their failure to shield their policyholder may place the insurer in a position of potential breach of contract and other potential legal liabilities. Our hope is this exposure will cause a positive change in insurer behaviors, regardless if a first- or third-party claim.”

You May Also Like

NORTHEAST 2024 Attendee Badge Registration Now Open

Individuals can now start registering for the NORTHEAST Automotive Services Show to be held March 15-17, 2024 at the Meadowlands Exposition Center.

The Alliance of Automotive Service Providers of New Jersey (AASP/NJ) announced that individuals can now start registering for the association's flagship event, the NORTHEAST Automotive Services Show, which returns March 15-17, 2024 to the Meadowlands Exposition Center in Secaucus, N.J.

Recognized as the largest and fastest growing show of its kind, NORTHEAST has supplied automotive professionals with an unmatched experience for 47 years. The show consistently offers the latest, most advanced equipment and a premium educational slate with some of the industry’s most knowledgeable minds providing guidance on current industry trends and offering advice on how to combat the latest challenges. 

ProColor Collision Adds Two New Locations in Houston

ProColor Collision announced that two new ProColor Collision locations in Houston are the latest to join ProColor Collision’s growing family of collision repair facilities in the U.S.  

Classic Collision Opens Second Location in Vancouver

Classic Collision St. John is located in an up-and-coming industrial development section of Clark County and one mile north of Classic’s Vancouver location.

Consolidator Report

Consolidation news from the week of Nov. 27.

Association News

The latest association news appearing on

Other Posts

Top 5 Stories of the Week

A recap of the top five stories on during the week of Nov. 27.

GUNIWHEEL Donates $20K to Operative Talent

Operative Talent is a car rebuild fundraising initiative with the goal of addressing the collision industry’s aging workforce.

ASE Offers Webinar on Pre-Paint Operating Procedures

The free webinar, “Pre-Paint Operating Procedures for Increased Productivity”, will be held on Tuesday, Dec. 5 at 4 p.m. EST.

Repairify, Autel Announce New Initiatives for 2024

In Q1 2024, Autel and Repairify will continue to enhance the value of their combined services for their users through various planned releases.