Viewpoint: Just Say No to Partial Refinish - BodyShop Business

Viewpoint: Just Say No to Partial Refinish

Most body shops don't address "partial refinish" on insurer estimates, but that's like letting money walk out the door.

We see this on many insurance company estimates: “partial refinish.” Most body shops just let it go and take the loss. Have you, as the owner of the shop, taken the time to consider how much money you’re letting slip out the door by letting this practice continue?

Let’s break it down. You’re working on a 2005 Toyota Highlander tailgate and have a four-hour dent. The estimating program gives you 3.7 hours to refinish, which breaks down to $118.40 in paint materials and $177.60 in labor for a total of $296. That’s not too bad, considering that all insurance companies refuse to pay for feather, prime and block. But with this formula, a shop only breaks even for this refinish job. There is simply no room to reduce refinish time.

Let’s see what happens if you let the insurance company bully you into a partial refinish. They reduce the refinish time to 2.3 hours. That’s $73.60 for paint material and $110.40 for labor for a total of $184.40. You just lost $111.10. Remember, you still have to feather, prime and block, which will result in another $80 loss, bringing the total loss to $191.10. The good news is that when you say, “We do not accept partial refinish,” 90 percent of insurance companies will give you full refinish.

Making Your Case
Some will ask, “How do I argue this with the insurance company?” Actually, it’s simple. Ask the adjuster, “What’s the actual difference in what we’ll be doing for a partial refinish and what we’ll be doing for a full refinish?” And then, before they can answer, answer the question yourself.

Explain how partial refinish actually costs more. We still have to clean and sand the entire panel, except with partial refinish, we have to sand much more slowly and carefully. And since that is the case, we now have to have a professional painter prep the panel, not a low-paid tech. This will cost the shop more. Also, we now must use a blending agent, which adds even more cost. Then, tell the adjuster, “We may have used $5 less in paint, but we’ve used more in blending agent and prep time. Now pay me to use my highly paid painter to prep and use blending agent, and also pay me to feather, prime and block sand, and I’ll be glad to accept partial refinish.”

Mike Watson co-owns Jim’s Body Shop LLC with his brother, James, in LaPlace, La. He can be reached at (985) 652-5804 or [email protected].

You May Also Like

Paint Problem Troubleshooting

Collision repair facilities today face many challenges with paint. Here are some common problems and how to overcome them.

Collision repair facilities today face many challenges with paint. Here are some common problems and how to overcome them.

Contaminants and Color

Meeting customer expectations at the time of delivery often boils down to the appearance of the vehicle repair. Nothing stands out more than a poor color match or contaminants in the finish. The best way to manage these issues is to create standard operating procedures and make sure your team follows them.

PPE and COVID-19

With COVID-19 bringing a heightened sense of self-protection to the forefront, now is the time to reinforce the importance of PPE in the body shop.

The Reality of PBE Value-Added Services

Both PBE distributors and manufacturers offer beneficial value-added services – but there is a catch.

Doctor Gun, I Presume?

One man who is still around who taught me about both spray guns and selling PBE products with enthusiasm was Doctor Gun.

Refinish: Separating Your Body Shop from the Competition

How can we showcase our refinishing skills in a manner that separates us from other shops and drives business to our door?

Other Posts

The Evolution of Spray Guns

Both spray gun technology and the cost of spray guns have increased dramatically since I first wrote about them in the September 1991 issue of BodyShop Business.

BASF Opens Modular OEM Coatings Lab in Germany

BASF’s Coatings division has opened a new laboratory for automotive OEM coatings at its site in Münster, Germany, aimed to ensure optimized, digitalized and transparent processes, and efficient use of resources in the laboratory area throughout Europe.

Protecting Yourself in the Paint Booth

Dad died in 2006 from respiratory failure. My brothers and I say the collision industry killed him, but it was really ignorance that did him in.

New Report Indicates Global Automotive Refinish Coatings Market Will Grow Over Next Few Years

The global automotive refinish coatings market is set to grow between 2018 and 2022, according to the “Global Automotive Refinish Coatings Market 2018-2022” report by