Why Was He Fired? - BodyShop Business

Why Was He Fired?

Progressive wasn't thrilled with me exposing the fact that they're now writing some paint times as 'judgment times.' In fact, they were furious," says Mark, a tech with 33 years experience who lost his job after sending in a "Letter to the Editor" about how area Progressive direct-repair shops are being told by adjusters that if they're not painting color on the whole panel, it's a blend and only pays partial paint time.

“When I got out the Mitchell P-Pages and told the adjuster those blend times are only intended for adjacent undamaged panels for the sole purpose of color match, he said it didn’t have anything to do with the estimating software and that this is what he was told to do by his supervisor. He also said that if we weren’t a DRP, we’d get book times.”
Along with the “Letter to the Editor,” Mark also sent in an estimate with the customer, vehicle and claim numbers blacked out – except for one claim number that was overlooked. But it wasn’t overlooked by Progressive – which traced the claim number back to the dealership where Mark worked.
Several things then happened:

  • Mark was told that Progressive had suspended the shop from its DRP.

  • Mark was told that he was being fired because he’d violated the privacy agreement he’d signed.

  • Mark was told that he was a great employee who did great work.

  • Mark found another job within an hour after he was fired.

    Says Mark: “Maybe now that I’m gone, Progressive will lift the suspension.” (Call me a conspiracy theorist, but I’d bet that suspension was lifted about seven seconds after Mark was fired.)

    When I told this story to repairers, most of them came to the same conclusion: The industry complains about a tech shortage, yet it doesn’t seem to value the few veteran techs it does have. A few repairers, however, also recognized the underlying morals of this story:

    1. It’s about offer and acceptance. Says one repairer: “Everyone’s eyes are wide open in these deals. Shops aren’t entitled to anything, much less a profit. And if they’re willing to sign on, they get what they deserve.” What happens, however, is that management agrees to these deals, unbeknownst to techs.

    2. Techs need to just say “No.” “Mark would’ve been better off (as would the industry at large) if he’d just said no to partial panel time for a full panel job,” says one repairer. “This is more of an indictment of the flat-rate/commission pay plans than of one insurer. If more techs said no, then management would have to demand more from insurers or opt out of the program. A shop paying flat rate won’t suffer under the Progressive program as long as its techs submit because the shop’s profit margin is guaranteed.”

      But not submitting is easier said than done. “We feel helpless,” says one tech. “If we complain too much, we’re shown the door. And what’s out there? Other shops with the same deals. When an insurer decides it’s going to adjust book paint times to its benefit, it’s in effect giving paint techs a cut in pay.” That’s partially true: Techs do risk their jobs by saying no. But it’s the SHOP, not the insurer, that’s cutting tech pay. The shop is agreeing to the terms and counting on techs to keep quiet and take it.

    3. Payers don’t dictate prices and procedures. Says one repairer: “In an unregulated industry like this one, prices are subject to whatever the market will bear. Payers do not control prices. You can use any guide you want and give written quotes in Euro exchange rates. It’s the availability and price of a quality repair that determines the market.”
      The problem is availability; insurer programs are designed to take advantage of an overcapacity in the body shop market. Says one repairer, “The fact that there are shops willing to sign onto programs that eliminate their right to price their own work is proof that many are either desperate, stupid or both.”

      Yes, I’m concerned that a shop would fire a veteran tech to appease an insurer. But I’m even more concerned that the majority
      of shop owners I spoke with didn’t recognize that Mark’s firing
      wasn’t as much about devaluing veteran techs as it was a symptom of bigger problems facing the industry.

      You May Also Like

      Body Bangin’: The Employer-Student Disconnect

      Micki Woods interviews Raven Hartkopf, lead collision instructor at Collin College in Texas, on what students want from a shop employer.

      Micki Woods, master marketer for collision repair shops and owner of Micki Woods Marketing, has released the latest episode of "Body Bangin'," the video podcast that is taking the industry by storm!

      In this episode, Woods interviews Raven Hartkopf, lead collision instructor at Collin College in Texas, on students' desire for shops to work around their school schedule and let them work part-time ... yet most shops don't offer a part-time position. If a shop does do this and is flexible with the student, once they're done with school, they typically stay with that shop and go full-time. Are shops missing an opportunity here?

      Body Bangin’: Why Follow OEM Repair Procedures?

      Micki Woods interviews Logan Payne of Payne & Sons Paint & Body Shop on the importance of following OEM repair procedures.

      Body Bangin’: Getting Paid for Calibrations

      Micki Woods interviews Andy Hipwell and James Rodis of OEM Calibration on how to get started doing ADAS calibrations.

      Body Bangin’: What Are The Consolidators Up To With Laura Gay

      Micki Woods interviews Laura Gay of Consolidation Coach on the current state of auto body shop consolidation.

      Body Bangin’: The Magic of a Massive MSO with Patrick Crozat

      Micki Woods interviews Patrick Crozat, the COO of G&C Auto Body, which is the largest privately-owned, family-owned auto body shop group.

      Other Posts

      Body Bangin’: Changing Your Mindset with Mike Jones

      Micki Woods interviews Mike Jones of Discover Leadership Training on changing your mindset to change your life.

      Body Bangin’: Rivian Collision Program and Insurance

      Micki Woods interviews Frank Phillips, collision repair program manager of Rivian, on how Rivian’s collision program works.

      Body Bangin’: Favorite Takeaways from the Southeast Conference

      Live from the Southeast Collision Conference, Micki Woods does a post-show wrap-up on the Southeast Collision Conference with the SCC committee.

      Body Bangin’: Overcoming Objections

      Live from the Southeast Collision Conference, Micki Woods interviews Ron Reichen and Barry Dorn on overcoming objections, the talent shortage and the SCRS blend study.