Maryland Body Shop Sues State Farm, Allstate over Steering

Maryland Body Shop Sues State Farm, Allstate Over Steering

Total Recon Auto Center is accusing the insurers of leading an "intentional, malicious campaign" against the repair center, which is an independent Tesla-certified shop.

Total Recon Auto Center, a Rockville, Md., auto body shop, has filed suit against State Farm and Allstate over improperly steering customers to cheaper and less qualified repair shops in order to save themselves money. 

Total Recon’s lawsuit accuses the insurers of leading an “intentional, malicious campaign” against the repair center, which is an independent Tesla-certified shop. At the core of the dispute is alleged “harmful misinformation” aimed at diverting Tesla owners to other shops willing to comply with the insurers’ preferred rates.

Per anti-steering laws in Maryland, after a wreck, consumers have the right to use any shop they want. But State Farm and Allstate have allegedly been “steering” their policyholders away from using Total Recon Auto Center.

State Farm allegedly sent a letter to customers acknowledging the customer’s right to choose the repair facility of their own choice, however, it then subtly warns of potential out-of-pocket costs at Total Recon, suggesting that the repair facility may charge more than what State Farm deems “reasonable.”

For Tesla owners, the right repair shop is paramount. Tesla vehicles, being semi-autonomous, require specific calibrations and parts replacements after accidents. Non-certified shops might not adhere to these standards, potentially compromising vehicle safety.

The lawsuit shines a light on State Farm’s alleged practice of emphasizing the benefits of choosing “in-network” shops. Insurers’ warnings about potential out-of-pocket costs can be misleading. Eduardo Garcia from Stein Sperling, the Rockville, Md., law firm handling the case, explains that in most scenarios, these costs are settled between the insurer and the repair shop. (Total Recon, for instance, has an agreement with State Farm to avoid charging customers out-of-pocket).

“This isn’t just a business dispute. It’s a loud wake-up call about consumers’ rights, safety, and the covert tactics that could be affecting your choices — and ultimately, your safety.”

You May Also Like

ASE to Offer Support at 2024 SkillsUSA Conference

ASE staffers will be on site at the Skills Conference to prepare and deliver tests during competitions in collision repair, auto maintenance and more.

The National Institute for Automotive Service Excellence (ASE) announced that its staff will be on site and providing support for the 2024 SkillsUSA National Leadership and Skills Conference (NLSC) June 24-28, 2024 at the Georgia World Congress Center in Atlanta.

“ASE is honored to be part of the SkillsUSA Conference again this year,” said Dave Johnson, president and CEO of ASE. “We support SkillsUSA in a variety of ways, including ASE staff serving on technical committees as well as providing tests for the competitions and educational support from the ASE Education Foundation.”

CIF Presents Check to Injured Collision Technician

The Collision Industry Foundation recently presented a check for $10,845 to Gary Noble, a collision technician who was involved in a major car accident last November.

Fix Auto USA Celebrates Grand Opening of 200th Store

Driven Brands announced that Fix Auto USA is celebrating the opening of its 200th location at Fix Auto Palm Desert South in California.

2024 SEMA Hall of Fame Inductees Announced

SEMA has announced the newest members of its prestigious Hall of Fame: Chris Kersting, Jack Priegel, Les Rudd  and Jon Wyly. 

Empire Auto Parts Expands Reach with New Distribution Facility in Texas

Aftermarket collision parts distributor opens 40th facility with new hub in Dallas.

Other Posts

NORTHEAST Named to Trade Show Executive Magazine’s “Fastest 50” List

The show was recognized for the second consecutive year as one of the fastest growing U.S. trade shows held in 2023.

People on the Move

Recent personnel news that has appeared on bodyshopbusiness.com.

Consolidator Report

Consolidation news from the week of April 29.

Top 5 Stories of the Week

A recap of the top five stories on bodyshopbusiness.com during the week of April 29.