Mid Island Collision Suit Against Allstate Goes to Federal Court - BodyShop Business

Mid Island Collision Suit Against Allstate Goes to Federal Court

A District Court judge has thrown out Allstate’s request for a summary judgment on claims of tortious interference and violation of unfair business practices law by Mid Island Collision of Rockville Centre, New York, allowing the case to move forward in Federal Court.

In 2007, Mid Island brought Allstate to court, alleging that the insurer pressured it to accept lower labor rates and refused to negotiate labor rates in good faith. When Allstate policyholders began to complain that the insurer would not approve Mid Island’s labor rates, Mid Island began to testify in assignment of proceeds lawsuits involving policyholders who pursued the difference between Allstate and Mid Island’s labor rates. Allstate paid Mid Island $38 per hour, but Mid Island’s labor rate was ordinarily $55 to $65 per hour.

Subsquently, Allstate told Mid Island it would not negotiate a labor rate with the shop under any circumstance. Further, Allstate allegedly told several policyholders that they should not use Mid Island because the shop overcharged and did not provide quality services.

The Court is permitting Mid Island to file an amended complaint to add defamation, but has requested that the shop submit specific evidence. Mid Island General Manager Brian McGauvran said the shop will be submitting around 200 examples of defamation to support its case.

“We have written affidavits from customers, recordings and more,” McGauvran said. “One of these customers is a judge.”

Mid Island has over 50 employees and is a multi-million-dollar shop. One of the shop’s allegations is that Allstate was sending customers “fraudulent” and “doctored” Notice of Rights. According to McGauvran, the Notice of Rights were supposed to say, “At your request, we can send you the names of shops that will do the repair work at our cost,” but he says Allstate was leaving out “at your request.”

McGauvran said the shop was left with no choice but to pursue legal action against Allstate.

“They were totaling cars to punish us and steering,” McGauvran said. “If we don’t do this, we’ll be out of business.”

The Federal Court trial is slated to begin sometime in October.

You May Also Like

National Auto Body Council Board of Directors Nomination Process Closing Soon

NABC Board of Directors nominations are due Sept. 6, 2019, 60 days prior to the NABC Annual Meeting and Board Elections on Nov. 6, 2019 at the 2019 SEMA Show in Las Vegas.

The National Auto Body Council (NABC) announced in early August that nominations were open for the NABC Board of Directors. The NABC board is comprised of collision repair industry companies and individuals representing the industry's thought leaders. These volunteer board members donate their time and expertise to lead the NABC and serve its industry membership.  

Cruise Postpones Release of Driverless Taxi Service

Cruise, a GM subsidiary, recently announced that it will miss its goal of launching a large-scale self-driving taxi service in 2019.

Cutting Edge Automotive Solutions Partners with Andretti Rallycross

Andretti Rallycross announced that Cutting Edge Automotive Solutions will serve as technical partner on Cabot Bigham’s No. 02 OINK Clothing Beetle for the remainder of the 2019 Americas Rallycross season, showcasing their SP Tools USA brand.

Ford, Volkswagen Expand Collaboration to Include Autonomous, Electric Vehicles

Ford Motor Company and Volkswagen AG announced they are expanding their global alliance to include electric vehicles – and will collaborate with Argo AI to introduce autonomous vehicle technology in the U.S. and Europe.

CCAR Updates Website with More OSHA Alliance Resources

CCAR (Coordinating Committee For Automotive Repair) has announced the addition of new Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) Alliance content on its main website, www.ccar-greenlink.org.

Other Posts

CARSTAR McLaren Lake Forest and CARSTAR McLaren Irvine Open in California

Owned by husband-and-wife team James and Mary Davis, CARSTAR McLaren Lake Forest and CARSTAR McLaren Irvine are a family business.

CIECA to Offer Webinar on What Businesses Need to Know to Implement CIECA Standards

CIECA will hold its next CIECAst webinar, “Implementing CIECA Standards: Implementation Guide and Appendix C – BMS, Code Lists and Shema Components,” on Tuesday, Dec. 11, 2018 at 11 a.m. CST.

CARSTAR Urges Customers to Stay Winter Ready

Cold weather can create some of the harshest driving conditions of the year. The months between October and February top the list for accidents, vehicle damage and injuries.

CIECA Adds Broadly as Corporate Member

The Collision Industry Electronic Commerce Association (CIECA) announced that Broadly has joined CIECA as a corporate member.