AASP/NJ Speaks Out on State Farm $250 Million Settlement - BodyShop Business

AASP/NJ Speaks Out on State Farm $250 Million Settlement

AASP/NJ Executive Director Charles Bryant calls State Farm's $250 million settlement in the Hale vs. State Farm class-action lawsuit a "travesty of justice."
AASP/NJ has released a statement in reaction to the recent $250 million State Farm settlement news.
The opening of the statement reads,”The collision repair industry was recently stunned by news that State Farm, the largest auto insurer in the nation, was granted preliminary approval of a $250 million settlement in lieu of going to trial in a federal class action suit (Hale et al. v. State Farm et al.)
The suit accused the company of rigging the Illinois justice system to overturn the $1 billion-plus verdict in the Avery et al. vs. State Farm aftermarket parts case of 1999.
The settlement was announced Sept. 4, the same day the trial was set to begin in East St. Louis, Ill. State Farm was accused of concealing millions in campaign contributions to Illinois Supreme Court Justice Lloyd A. Karmeier prior to the court reversing the Avery verdict in 2005. The Hale suit sought nearly $10 billion in damages. State Farm claimed the reason behind settling was to put an end to the litigation and prevent a lengthy legal process. A final fairness hearing has been set for December.
Alliance of Automotive Service Providers of New Jersey (AASP/NJ) President Jerry McNee and Executive Director Charles Bryant have spoken out about this recent development. McNee says he was not surprised that State Farm would want to settle before the case gained too much public traction.
“It’s just how big business works – or insurance companies, in this case,” said McNee. “They realize they are in a jam and are willing to throw money at something to protect themselves in the long run, which makes it tough for the smaller businesses like the body shops to compete with the big giants in the industry. It’s believed that they paid to have this judge put in place; for repayment, he ruled in their favor, and that’s something that body shops just don’t have any privilege to. It’s hard for the body shops to have any traction when they are up against the bullies because they are making all the laws, rules and regulations. Even when they are wrong, they have someone willing to side with them.”
Bryant called it a “travesty of justice.”
“When I heard about the settlement, I first thought that maybe I was dreaming,” said Bryant. “I could have swallowed heavy and lived with a $250 million settlement to bring this to an end. To hear that State Farm gets to deny liability and consider the claims without merit after 20 years of litigation that started because an insurer attempted to shortchange its own insureds, ultimately going so far as to be accused and sued for basically buying a judge to get its way while claiming to be ‘your good neighbor’…That will never sit right with me. Anyone who conducts themselves in such a manner is not someone I would consider a good neighbor.”
For more information on AASP/NJ visit aaspnj.org or call (732) 922-8909.
You May Also Like

Survey Finds More Body Shops Researching OEM Repair Procedures

The latest “Who Pays for What?” survey indicates that 61% of shops say they’re researching OE procedures on “all” or “most” vehicles.

The latest "Who Pays for What?" survey from Collision Advice and CRASH Network indicates that more than three in five shops (61%) say they're researching automaker repair procedures on “all” or “most” of the vehicles they repair, a nine percentage point gain since 2020.

“It’s still not a high enough percentage, because this must be done every time, but at least awareness of this vital step is increasing,” said Mike Anderson of Collision Advice, who conducts the quarterly surveys with CRASH Network. “OEM information is complex, and can change. I recently wrote an estimate on three of the same year and model of vehicles, but the alignment procedures and battery disconnect procedures were different based on trim levels and engine types.”

Classic Collision Expands into Florida Keys

Classic Collision has announced the acquisition of Cooper’s Paint & Body Shop in Key West, Fla.

People on the Move

Recent personnel news that has appeared on bodyshopbusiness.com.

Consolidator Report

Consolidation news from the week of July 1.

CIECA to Hold Webinar on V2X Technology

The webinar, “Why the Collision Industry Should Be Interested in V2X,” will be held on July 25 at 2 p.m. EST.

Other Posts
Top 5 Stories of the Week

A recap of the top five stories on bodyshopbusiness.com during the week of July 1.

Tint World Expands Texas Footprint with East Houston Location

The National Automotive Styling Centers franchise announced the opening of its 25th store in the state.

GFS Names Platinum Equipment Preferred Refinish Distributor for Illinois

Founded in 2020, Platinum Equipment supplies, installs and services a variety of automotive repair equipment, including paint booths and frame racks.

Global Finishing Solutions, GFC logo
Fix Network to Host 2025 Global Conference in Mexico

The conference will take place April 27-May 1, 2025 at the Dreams Playa Mujeres Golf & Spa Resort in Mexico.