California Fines Two Insurers $505,000 Each for Hundreds of Claims Violations - BodyShop Business
Connect with us


Close Sidebar Panel Open Sidebar Panel


California Fines Two Insurers $505,000 Each for Hundreds of Claims Violations


California Insurance Commissioner Steve Poizner announced that a settlement has been reached in an enforcement action against Civil Service Employees Insurance Company and CSE Safeguard Insurance Company. The settlement marks the end of a market conduct examination that found numerous violations of the Insurance Code and Regulations for the period May 1, 2005 through April 30, 2006. Specifically, Department of Insurance (DOI) examiners reviewed the companies’ claims handling practices in automobile, homeowners and commercial liability lines of insurance, randomly selected 596 claim files closed during the review period and found 661 claim-handling violations.

Click Here to Read More

The violations include such acts as:

• failing to provide their
policyholders with necessary facts, including policy provisions and
other pertinent policy information upon filing of a claim

• failing to
properly advise the insured of the determination of fault

• failing to
provide the claimant with a copy of an automobile repair estimate

• failing to provide the claimant with a written basis for total automobile
loss settlement

• failing to pay all fees and taxes incident to an
automobile total loss settlement

• failing to explain the basis for

• failing to effectuate prompt, fair and equitable
settlements of claims

• failing to adhere to the claims processing
laws of the State of California

"Let me be clear — I will continue to pursue and sanction any insurance company that engages in such gross misconduct," Poizner said. "The laundry list of violations perpetrated by each of these companies is unacceptable. I am pleased with the work of my department in holding them accountable for their irresponsible actions. This settlement is a victory for policyholders in California, as well as a notice to all insurers that deficient and illegal business practices will not be tolerated."


This is not the first time that these companies were charged with violating the Insurance Code. A prior examination, for the period May 2000 through April 2001, uncovered violations similar to the ones identified in the 2005-2006 examination. The companies paid $155,000 to settle those charges. The current settlement was preceded by a two-week hearing in Oakland that was continued to August 2010 for additional testimony. The settlement was reached during the recess of the hearing.

The order, signed Sept. 20, 2010, requires the two companies to cease and desist from the acts in which violations were found and pay a $505,000 monetary penalty, $450,000 of which was applied under California Insurance Code Sections 790.03 and 790.035, with the remaining $55,000 applied under sections 790.05 and 790.07. 

Click to comment
BodyShop Business