Consumer Federation of America Study Reveals Insurers Raise Premiums After Not-At-Fault Accidents

Consumer Federation of America Study Reveals Insurers Raise Premiums After Not-At-Fault Accidents

Study reveals premiums can rise $300 or more for drivers rear-ended while safely stopped at a red light; price hikes prohibited in some states.

Safe drivers who are in accidents caused by others often see auto insurance rate hikes, according to recently released research by the Consumer Federation of America (CFA). The research analyzed premium quotes in 10 cities from five of the nation’s largest auto insurers. Among the cities tested, drivers in New York City and Baltimore pay out the most for doing nothing wrong, and customers in Chicago and Kansas City also face average increases of 10 percent or more when another driver crashes into them.

“Innocent drivers who don’t cause accidents should not be charged more because someone else hit them,” said J. Robert Hunter, CFA’s director of insurance and the former insurance commissioner of Texas. “Most people know that if they cause an accident or get a ticket they could face a premium increase, but they don’t expect to be punished if a reckless driver careens into them.”

CFA called on lawmakers around the country to prohibit such penalties on innocent drivers.

“Penalizing safe drivers hit by another car is not only very unfair; it also discourages them from filing legitimate claims,” said Hunter. “Lawmakers and regulators need to protect consumers from being punished when they’ve done nothing more than use the policy they have already paid for.”

At least two states already prohibit such penalties. While drivers in eight of the 10 cities tested by CFA can be surcharged if they’re hit by another driver, CFA research found that consumer protections in California and Oklahoma prevent insurance companies from raising rates on drivers in those states when they are involved in an accident that was not their fault.

Some Companies More Unfair Than Others

There are significant differences in the way the five companies CFA tested treat customers after accidents they did not cause. Progressive used the not-at-fault penalty most aggressively, surcharging drivers in every test where such an increase is not prohibited by state law. GEICO and Farmers sometimes raised rates by 10 percent or more for not-at-fault accidents. Allstate occasionally penalized drivers who did not cause the accident, while State Farm never increased premiums for these accidents.

Being Hit by Another Motorist Costs More for Lower Income Drivers

The increases charged for not-at-fault accidents vary from customer to customer, even for the same company in the same city. CFA’s research over recent years has consistently found that good drivers with certain socio-economic characteristics that suggest lower incomes generally pay more for auto insurance than higher-income drivers with the same driving record. This pattern holds when it comes to penalizing drivers for accidents in which they were not at fault.

Comparing two good drivers, whose only differences reflected their individual socio-economic circumstances rather than their driving safety record, CFA found the following:

  • Higher-income drivers paid $78 more on average after a not-at-fault accident
  • Moderate-income drivers paid $208 more on average after a not-at-fault accident
  • Higher-income drivers faced a 6.6 percent penalty on average after a not-at-fault accident
  • Moderate-income drivers faced a 9.6 percent penalty on average after a not-at-fault accident

Excluding State Farm customers, who were never penalized, the average surcharges jumped to $99 (8.3 percent) for higher-income drivers and $264 (12.1 percent) for moderate-income drivers.

Premium Hikes for Not-At-Fault Accidents Adds to the Unaffordability of Auto Insurance Identified by Recent Federal Insurance Office Study

According to CFA, more than 18 million residents living in 845 ZIP codes across the country face basic auto insurance premiums that have been deemed unaffordable by the United States Treasury Department’s Federal Insurance Office (FIO). For drivers living in states where insurance companies can charge more for not-at-fault accidents, some good drivers find premiums even further out of reach, despite having done nothing wrong.

The FIO report, released in its first Auto Affordability Study in January and available here, calculated the average premium charged to drivers in underserved ZIP Codes across the country for state minimum limits liability insurance, the insurance coverage required in every state but New Hampshire. More than 18 million Americans live in ZIP codes where the average premium for basic insurance is more than 2 percent of the median household income in that community. Because most drivers have not been involved in a recent accident, the average premiums identified in the study are lower than the actual premiums drivers are likely to face when insurance companies penalize them for having been hit by another driver who caused an accident. That would leave auto insurance even more unaffordable for many good drivers who are already struggling to comply with state insurance mandates.

“We already have a severe problem in this country, because so many Americans live in communities where auto insurance is unaffordable,” said Douglas Heller, an insurance expert who conducted the research along with CFA’s Michelle Styczynski. “State leaders should at least prevent insurance companies from punishing good drivers for having the bad luck of being in the vicinity of someone else’s bad driving.”

You May Also Like

RDA Holds Fall IMPACT Performance Conference in Denver

The Refinish Distributors Alliance held their Fall Membership Meeting Sept. 20-22, 2023 at the Embassy Suites Downtown Denver, Colo.

The Refinish Distributors Alliance (RDA) held their Fall Membership Meeting Sept. 20-22, 2023 at the Embassy Suites Downtown Denver, Colo., with Ben Jacobson welcoming members and manufacturer partners for the first time as the executive director of RDA.  

The conference saw a record turnout, which included RDA members, manufacturer partners and guests. Jacobson opened the meeting with a day of member discussions followed by a welcome reception at the Denver Opera House. The next day, everyone enjoyed the annual rodeo, an engaging and productive one-on-one event between RDA members and manufacturer partners that offered valuable relationship-building time and special promotions. Keynote speaker Mark Sanborn gave an insightful presentation followed by a book signing provided to all attendees. RDA ended the evening with a partner appreciation dinner and entertainment by Dennis Watkins, an award-winning, third-generation magician and entertainer.  

AASP/NJ Celebrates Return of Lou Scoras Annual Golf Outing

The AASP/NJ recently celebrated the return of its annual Lou Scoras Memorial Golf Outing at Knob Hill Country Club in Manalapan, N.J.

Consolidator Report

Consolidation news from the week of Sept. 18.

Association News

The latest association news appearing on

Top 5 Stories of the Week

A recap of the top five stories on during the week of Sept. 18.

Other Posts

NABC Donates Recycled Ride to Deserving Chicago Mom

The NABC, Travelers and Gerber Collision & Glass recently donated a refurbished vehicle to a deserving Chicago-area mom.

Mitchell Wins Award for Cloud Computing

Mitchell won the 2023 Stratus Award, which recognizes their patented technology designed to optimize a key step in the auto insurance claims process.

BMW, Ford and Honda Create Company to Optimize EV Grid

ChargeScape, LLC will create a single, cost-effective platform connecting electric utilities, automakers and interested EV customers.

Auto Care Association Launches Auto Care Academy

The Auto Care Academy is a convenient, self-paced online learning resource for auto care industry professionals.