Court Rules California Couple Entitled to Diminished Value from Mercury Insurance - BodyShop Business

Court Rules California Couple Entitled to Diminished Value from Mercury Insurance

Attorney Montie Day says Mercury can no longer say that a claimant is not entitled to diminished value in State of California.

The Superior Court of the State of California has ruled that James Scott and Patricia Scott are entitled to diminished value from Mercury Insurance Company, notwithstanding that their vehicle had been repaired. Judgment was entered, and no appeal was filed within 60 days as permitted by California law. Thus, the judgment was made final.

What distinguishes this case from all others, says Montie Day, attorney for the plaintiffs, is that it’s an “unlimited jurisdiction case,” meaning that it has sufficient legal effect, or “collateral estoppel,” on future litigation or claims made by Mercury.

“Thus, for future claims against Mercury Insurance Company, the doctrine of collateral estoppel should bar Mercury from alleging that a claimant is not entitled to consideration for diminished value in California,” says Day. “Furthermore, the denial of such claims on the basis that Californians are not entitled to claim diminished value against Mercury would be subject to a violation of the California Insurance Code and should be reported to the state’s insurance commissioner.”

For years, Day claims that Mercury has denied in California that it or its insureds are liable for diminished value based upon California law.

“This, among other practices, including suggesting that the victim-claimant can avoid the damages from diminished value by simply selling the vehicle to an individual without disclosing that the vehicle was in an accident, has resulted in Mercury avoiding such liability on a massive scale in that the average consumer/insured does not have the ability to litigate against such insurance giants,” says Day.

“If Mercury continues its current practices, the California state insurance commissioner may bring an action against them, which he has failed to do for years. Furthermore, it would appear that attorneys, including personal injury attorneys who have principally ignored this issue, are now obligated to seek such relief on behalf of the clients and the public against Mercury and other insurance companies. With respect to Mercury, such attorneys may use a ‘certified’ copy of the judgment and jury verdict with the collateral estoppel argument to defeat Mercury’s claim that a claimant-victim is not entitled to diminished value if the vehicle was repaired.

“This should be a wake-up call on this issue. An attorney has an ethical duty to represent the claim of the clients for diminished value and not attempt to limit their professional duties and their liability for malpractice only to personal injury damages.”

Day cited a 1994 study by the Florida Attorney General that estimated that, in Florida, insurers were underpaying claims by $1 billion per year. Based on that data, Day believes the figure in California could be as much as $3 to $4 billion.

You May Also Like

HD Repair Forum Announces Dates and Location for Technical Training

The HD Repair Forum will be hosting technical training April 26-27, 2024 at the Hyatt Regency in Frisco, Texas.

The HD Repair Forum will be hosting technical training April 26-27, 2024 at the Hyatt Regency in Frisco, Texas. Heavy- and medium-duty service and collision repair technicians will be able to take advantage of two days of training classes.

Five of these classes will be taught by Bendix Commercial Vehicle Systems and will feature diagnostics and repair of:

Nebraska MSO Acquires Speidell Body Works

Eustis Body Shop has announced the addition of Speidell Body Works into its family of body shops throughout Nebraska.

WIN Announces Speakers, Programs for 2024 Conference

The conference, which this year is themed “Dream Out Loud,” will celebrate women in the collision repair industry.

AkzoNobel Announces Automotive & Specialty Coatings Leadership Changes

John Griffin, Dan Carranza and Dustin Warren have all seen changes to their roles in Automotive & Specialty Coatings and U.S. Vehicle Refinishes Sales.

Guess the Car and Win $50!

Give us your answer for this month’s Guess the Car and you might win $50!

Other Posts

Auto Glass Now Builds National Brand

All-Star Glass, Horizon Auto Glass, A1 Auto Glass, Auto Glass Fitters and Discount Auto Glass have been rebranded and remodeled to Auto Glass Now’s brand identity.

NABC Donates Recycled Ride to Deserving Chicago Family

The NABC, Allstate and Gold Coast Auto Body recently donated a refurbished vehicle to a deserving Chicago resident.

Hunter Engineering to Exhibit HawkEye XL Aligner at TMC

New commercial alignment system offers speed, versatility and ease of use.

Crash Network Releases Results of 2024 Insurer Report Card

A record-high 19 companies, including six of the largest U.S. auto insurers, received a grade of C- or lower.