OEM, Aftermarket Debate Crash Part Patents at CIC - BodyShop Business

OEM, Aftermarket Debate Crash Part Patents at CIC

A lively debate at the recent Collision Industry Conference in Las Vegas had a former Keystone executive facing off with a Ford Motor Company attorney on crash part design patents and the new Access to Repair Parts Act (H.R. 3059/S. 1368) introduced to Congress in 2009 that would favor the aftermarket and create an exception from infringement of design patents for certain component parts used to repair another article of manufacture.

Dan Morrissey, former vice president of Keystone Automotive Services and current owner of New Horizon Advisors, LLC, accused Ford of trying to gain a monopoly over the sale of commonly used replacement crash parts by eliminating competition through seeking design patent protection. He cited a case that resulted in a win for Ford and a ban on the importation of seven different types of crash parts. A settlement was reached where LKQ, as the only distributor of non-OEM aftermarket copies of Ford collision parts protected by design patents, would pay Ford a royalty for each such part sold during the agreement’s term, which extends through Sept. 30, 2011.

“The impact was fewer choices and higher prices,” Morrissey said. “It was a resolution to the litigation but not a solution to the problem.”

Morrissey said Ford, as the sole source for select crash parts for 14 years (the duration of the design patents), now has the power to price gouge. To prove his point, he showed a graphic in his presentation where the prices for the parts Ford won protection over supposedly went up drastically and immediately after the court decision was handed down. Ford later disputed the information, with Paul Massey, Ford’s product marketing manager, saying the parts listed were “unfairly cherry picked.” Massey said without specific part numbers, the information was highly questionable.

Morrissey listed these other consequences of the court decision in favor of Ford:

• Lack of choice

• Higher parts prices = more total losses

• Increased consumer and insurance costs

• Fewer cars to repair

Benefits of competition he cited were:

• Faster delivery to shops

• Broader availability for older models

• Margin improvement

• OE price matching program

• Improved quality/certification programs

• Better warranties

Damian Procuri, an attorney with Ford’s intellectual property group, immediately went on the defensive and opened by saying, “Were there any job losses in the aftermarket or repair industry? The people we sued, LKQ, reported record profits. I hope Ford can someday.”

Procuri said Ford has pursued design patent protection because modern technology is making it much easier to clone parts.

“It takes thousands of hours to design fenders, hoods and lights,” Procuri said. “But now, high-speed laser scanners, rapid tooling and low-wage offshore manufacturing has made it faster, cheaper and more profitable to copy everything. The Taiwanese can clone our parts in under a day. And the copying of parts in every industry will continue to grow.”

Procuri said enforcing design patents is a 100-year-old concept and does not negatively impact the industry. He said inventors from the aftermarket also have the freedom to protect their patents. Other observations he made were:

• It’s always cheaper to make copies.

• The aftermarket copies the outside, not the inside.

• Insurers want copies, not customers.

• Consumers don’t know they’re getting copies.

• Insurance premiums are based on OE prices.

Addressing Morrissey’s point that aftermarket crash parts provide more choice in the market, Procuri said, “You don’t have to copy a Ford part to provide choice.”

The specific language of the Access to Repair Parts Act, which was introduced on June 25, 2009 and currently sits in committee, makes it not an act of infringement of any design patent to make, use, offer to sell, sell, or import into the United States any article that is a component part of another article, if the sole purpose of the component part is for the repair of the article of which it is a part so as to restore its original appearance.

“Three hundred thousand U.S. parts jobs have been lost since 2000, and Taiwanese parts have skyrocketed from 1989 to 2002,” Procuri said. “This bill would turbocharge that process. It is a clumsy attack on Detroit that will take down dozens of industries and jobs.”


More information:

ITC Sees Increase in Section 337 Patent Infringement Cases

Ford Files Design Patent Infringement Complaint on Mustang

Ford and LKQ Settle Patent Disputes

You May Also Like

Body Bangin’: The Employer-Student Disconnect

Micki Woods interviews Raven Hartkopf, lead collision instructor at Collin College in Texas, on what students want from a shop employer.

Micki Woods, master marketer for collision repair shops and owner of Micki Woods Marketing, has released the latest episode of "Body Bangin'," the video podcast that is taking the industry by storm!

In this episode, Woods interviews Raven Hartkopf, lead collision instructor at Collin College in Texas, on students' desire for shops to work around their school schedule and let them work part-time ... yet most shops don't offer a part-time position. If a shop does do this and is flexible with the student, once they're done with school, they typically stay with that shop and go full-time. Are shops missing an opportunity here?

Body Bangin’: Why Follow OEM Repair Procedures?

Micki Woods interviews Logan Payne of Payne & Sons Paint & Body Shop on the importance of following OEM repair procedures.

Body Bangin’: Getting Paid for Calibrations

Micki Woods interviews Andy Hipwell and James Rodis of OEM Calibration on how to get started doing ADAS calibrations.

Body Bangin’: What Are The Consolidators Up To With Laura Gay

Micki Woods interviews Laura Gay of Consolidation Coach on the current state of auto body shop consolidation.

Body Bangin’: The Magic of a Massive MSO with Patrick Crozat

Micki Woods interviews Patrick Crozat, the COO of G&C Auto Body, which is the largest privately-owned, family-owned auto body shop group.

Other Posts

Body Bangin’: Changing Your Mindset with Mike Jones

Micki Woods interviews Mike Jones of Discover Leadership Training on changing your mindset to change your life.

Body Bangin’: Rivian Collision Program and Insurance

Micki Woods interviews Frank Phillips, collision repair program manager of Rivian, on how Rivian’s collision program works.

Body Bangin’: Favorite Takeaways from the Southeast Conference

Live from the Southeast Collision Conference, Micki Woods does a post-show wrap-up on the Southeast Collision Conference with the SCC committee.

Body Bangin’: Overcoming Objections

Live from the Southeast Collision Conference, Micki Woods interviews Ron Reichen and Barry Dorn on overcoming objections, the talent shortage and the SCRS blend study.