Federal Court Denies Most of Progressive’s Motion to Dismiss Professionals Auto Body Lawsuit

Federal Court Denies Most of Progressive’s Motion to Dismiss Professionals Auto Body Lawsuit

Judge Kim Gibson of the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Pennsylvania denied Progressive’s motion to dismiss the case for three of the lawsuit’s four claims, which means Professionals Auto Body can pursue its case against Progressive for alleged breach of contract, bad faith and unjust enrichment.

A federal court has denied most of Progressive’s motion to dismiss a lawsuit filed by Professionals Auto Body of Altoona and Duncansville, Pa.

Judge Kim Gibson of the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Pennsylvania denied Progressive’s motion to dismiss the case for three of the lawsuit’s four claims, which means Professionals Auto Body can pursue its case against Progressive for alleged breach of contract, bad faith and unjust enrichment.

Gibson granted Progressive’s motion to dismiss the lawsuit’s claim of tortious interference against the insurer.

In August 2017, Professionals Auto Body owner Ron Perretta filed a lawsuit against more than two dozen insurers – including Progressive – in the Blair County (Pa.) Court of Common Pleas. The lawsuit contends that the insurance companies don’t pay enough to cover the costs of making proper repairs, and notes that Professionals Auto Body entered into assignment-of-proceeds agreements with consumers to recover any unpaid balances for the shop’s repairs.

In September, the county court granted Progressive’s request to break off from the larger case. The case then moved to the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Pennsylvania, where Progressive filed a motion to dismiss the case.

Gibson ruled that Professionals Auto Body has stated “plausible” claims for alleged breach of contract, bad faith and unjust enrichment. To win the case, Professionals will have to present evidence to substantiate those claims.

“Professionals alleges that Progressive failed to reimburse it for the full amount of the reasonable and necessary repairs without a valid justification,” Gibson wrote in her analysis of Professionals’ bad faith claim. “Furthermore, Progressive knew of or recklessly disregarded this lack of a reasonable basis because it failed to fully reimburse Professionals despite Professionals informing Progressive on several occasions that it had failed to pay the full cost of all reasonable and necessary repairs on each of the vehicles that Professionals serviced. Professionals began sending ‘supplements’ to Progressive notifying them about the unpaid repairs as early as the fall of 2013. The fact that Progressive has a long history of failing to fully reimburse Professionals supports Professionals’ argument that Progressive acted in bad faith.”

You May Also Like

New Trends Report Highlights Vehicles with Higher Claim Frequencies

Higher claim severities, rising risky driving behavior by Gen Z, longer claims processes and more are detailed in the LexisNexis Risk Solutions report.

LexisNexis Risk Solutions has released its 2024 U.S. Auto Insurance Trends Report, which aggregates annual market data about consumer driving patterns, auto insurance shopping trends, claim frequency and severity, and consumer responses to rate increases to help insurance carriers better understand the evolving trends impacting the U.S. auto insurance industry. 

PRT Launches 94 New Strut Assemblies in North America

The new strut assemblies cover over 15 million vehicles, expanding the PRT portfolio in the North American aftermarket.

SEMA Announces Board of Directors Selection Results

SEMA members vote Bill Bader, Doug Lane, Kelle Oeste, Kim Pendergast and Melissa Scoles to lead the association.

Live from the Southeast Collision Conference Body Bangin’ Podcasts

A roundup of the latest Body Bangin’ podcasts live from the Southeast Collision Conference.

Consolidator Report

Consolidation news from the week of June 17.

Other Posts

Top 5 Stories of the Week

A recap of the top five stories on bodyshopbusiness.com during the week of June 17.

Crash Champions Expands in Georgia

Crash Champions has announced the acquisition of Pro Body Shop and Frame Works in Thomasville, Ga. 

Matthew’s Auto Supplies Invites AASP/NJ Members to Free Training Event

AASP/NJ President Ken Miller Benjamin Stephens will present “Negotiation Tactics for Today’s Collision Repair Environment” and “Documentation for Stronger Negotiations.”

ASE President Addresses Industry on Accreditation Process

Dave Johnson emphasizes that automotive program accreditation ensures that students are taught the important skills that employers are looking for when hiring entry-level automotive service professionals.