Dallas Couple Plans to Re-File Lawsuit Against State Farm; Attorney Believes Case Is Strong

Dallas Couple Plans to Re-File Lawsuit Against State Farm; Attorney Believes Case Is Strong

The Seebachans’ attorney said they plan to re-file the State Farm complaint when the trial for their related lawsuit against John Eagle Collision Center is over.

State Farm

State Farm might not be out of the woods yet.

Matthew and Marcia Seebachan recently dropped their “neighbor from hell” lawsuit against State Farm for the insurer’s alleged role in a slapdash repair that exacerbated their injuries in a 2013 collision.

But the Seebachans’ attorney said they plan to re-file the State Farm complaint when the trial for their related lawsuit against John Eagle Collision Center is over.

The John Eagle trial is scheduled for Sept. 25.

“We’ve been ready to go to trial against John Eagle for several months now, so we don’t want to do anything that would affect that trial date,” Andy Counts of the Dallas-based Tracy Law Firm told BodyShop Business. “Once the trial with John Eagle is over, we will be re-filing the case against State Farm.”

In the lawsuit against John Eagle Collision Center – which seeks more than $1 million in damages – the Seebachans allege that the body shop ignored the OEM specifications when repairing the hail-damaged roof of their 2010 Honda Fit before they owned it.

In a deposition, the body shop director said insurers dictate the shop’s repair procedures.

Since filing the State Farm lawsuit, the Tracy Law Firm has been emboldened by feedback from other collision repairers, according to Counts.

“We’ve received calls from various other body shops or people who used to be affiliated with body shops trying to give us information about what State Farm has done to them, what State Farm has done in other states,” he told BodyShop Business.

“Whether that would be relevant or admissible in our case against State Farm, I don’t know. But apparently there are a lot of people in the body shop industry who have negative things to say about State Farm or who have had negative experiences with State Farm for these same types of issues.

“So we’ve seen nothing that would dissuade us or make us change our opinion of our case against State Farm. In fact, the reverse is true.”

You May Also Like

SCRS Updates BOT Estimating Tool

Shop managers can now better maximize usage and benefits from the estimate analysis tool.

The Society of Collision Repair Specialists (SCRS) has announced the release of a new dashboard and expanded reporting functionality within the award-winning Blueprint Optimization Tool (BOT) powered by SCRS’ development partner OEC — an intelligent, easy-to-use estimate analysis tool that immediately identifies labor operations, line items and customizable charges that could be overlooked on an estimate.

NORTHEAST 2024 Attendee Badge Registration Now Open

Individuals can now start registering for the NORTHEAST Automotive Services Show to be held March 15-17, 2024 at the Meadowlands Exposition Center.

ProColor Collision Adds Two New Locations in Houston

ProColor Collision announced that two new ProColor Collision locations in Houston are the latest to join ProColor Collision’s growing family of collision repair facilities in the U.S.  

Classic Collision Opens Second Location in Vancouver

Classic Collision St. John is located in an up-and-coming industrial development section of Clark County and one mile north of Classic’s Vancouver location.

Consolidator Report

Consolidation news from the week of Nov. 27.

Other Posts

Association News

The latest association news appearing on bodyshopbusiness.com.

Top 5 Stories of the Week

A recap of the top five stories on bodyshopbusiness.com during the week of Nov. 27.

GUNIWHEEL Donates $20K to Operative Talent

Operative Talent is a car rebuild fundraising initiative with the goal of addressing the collision industry’s aging workforce.

ASE Offers Webinar on Pre-Paint Operating Procedures

The free webinar, “Pre-Paint Operating Procedures for Increased Productivity”, will be held on Tuesday, Dec. 5 at 4 p.m. EST.